Editorial Policy & Research Methodology
Who writes the Tinor Journal, how articles are researched and reviewed, what each evidence label means, and how dates, revisions and corrections are handled.
Who writes the Journal
Articles are published under the byline Tinor Research: the Tinor team writing as a group. It is a team byline, not a pseudonym for one person, and we do not attribute articles to named individuals at this stage. Tinor builds the Real-World State Runtime discussed in many articles; see interests and independence.
How articles are made
- Each article starts from a question Tinor works on in its own protocol and product design. Claims about Tinor are checked against Tinor's design records and its reference implementation before publication; where an article says a behaviour is tested, the tests were re-run for that article.
- External claims are checked against the cited source. Quotations are verbatim; links are checked when an article is published or revised.
- Drafting may be assisted by AI writing tools. AI output is treated like any other draft: the argument, the sources, the code and every factual claim are reviewed by the Tinor team, and AI tools are never listed as authors.
- We do not publish customer cases, quotes, endorsements, experiment results or benchmark numbers that we do not have. Where data would be needed, an article proposes how to collect it and says that it has not been collected.
Evidence labels
Every article lists the evidence labels that apply to it, and sections carry their own label where the evidence level changes within an article. A label describes the evidence behind a passage, not the quality of the writing.
- External Reference
- Restates or quotes a published external source (standard, paper, documentation). The source is linked; the claim is the source's, not Tinor's.
- Original Analysis
- Tinor's own argument, derivation or judgment. It can be wrong; counterarguments and limits are stated in the article.
- Design Proposal
- A recorded design decision or proposal. It describes intended behaviour and is not evidence that the behaviour exists or works.
- Synthetic Illustration
- A constructed example with fictional parties and data. When it is executable, the model and fixture are published so readers can reproduce it. It is not a customer case.
- Implemented
- Behaviour that exists in Tinor's reference implementation and is exercised by automated tests that Tinor re-ran for the article. Scope is limited to the claim types named.
- Measured
- A number produced by a stated method on a stated dataset, with sample size and date. No Journal article carries this label yet.
- Independently Verified
- Reproduced or reviewed by a party outside Tinor, who is named. No Journal article carries this label yet.
Article types
Different questions need different structures; we do not force one template.
- Perspective
- An original thesis, the strongest counterarguments, the boundary where the thesis stops applying, and how it was derived.
- Engineering Note
- A problem, its constraints, the design, counterexamples, the tests that exercise it, and how to reproduce the result.
- Research Note
- A research question, the method, the experiment (or its design, clearly marked as not yet run), results if any, and limitations.
- Field Note
- A real scenario, the evidence available, the problem, how it was handled, and the outcome. Published only with the consent of everyone involved.
- Benchmark Report
- Measured results from a stated method and dataset, with sample sizes, baselines and uncertainty. Used only when such results exist.
Sources and citations
- Every article ends with References. We prefer primary sources: standards, specifications, papers and official documentation.
- When an article describes an existing mechanism, it says so and cites it; we do not present established work as Tinor's.
- Examples with fictional parties are labelled Synthetic Illustration. When an example is executable, its model and data are published as research attachments so that readers can reproduce every number in it.
- Tinor's internal source code and design records are not public. Articles describe tested behaviour, not private code.
Dates and revisions
- Pages show the month of first publication. The publication date never changes.
- Small edits — typos, wording, broken links — are made silently and do not change the revision date.
- A substantive revision — new evidence, a corrected claim, a new section — is recorded in the article's update log with a summary, and only then is the article's modified date changed.
Corrections
If you find an error, contact us. Corrections of substance are recorded in the update log of the affected article, including what was wrong.
Interests and independence
Tinor has a commercial interest in the problems the Journal discusses. Statements that something is implemented or tested are Tinor's own unless an article carries the Independently Verified label and names the party that verified it. No Journal article carries that label yet. We welcome replication of any published reference model.